The Coded Couture of Antique Lacework

Portrait of Ana de Velasco y Girón (1585-1607), Duchess of Braganza

They were like snowflakes spun from silk, sought after just as feverishly as gold on the black market. Whether they were twisted with pearls or tied with silver knots, no two pieces of lace were the same in 1765. All too often forgotten in dusty attics today, for centuries, lacework was all about how you flaunted your individuality. Lace helped you tell a story by weaving a veritable comic book strip of characters on the cuff of your sleeve. From biblical tales to mythical beasts, eternal flowers and chivalric scenes, let’s take a little walk through history’s best pieces of coded couture…

17th century English needle lace, with seed pearls and glass beads tells the story King Solomon’s Judgement ©Victoria and Albert Museum
17th century portrait
Puncetto Lace
Fragment17th century. Italian, Venice / The Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Portrait attributed to William Larkin, 17th century

Unlike, say, the equally complicated and enchanting Jacobean needlework of the era, which was primarily made by men in guilds, lace craftsmanship seems to have flourished in high and low echelons of society, in common domestic spheres and royal couture alike; “Lace was also made at home, for the decoration of household linen, clothing and other objects,” explain the specialists at the Victoria and Albert Museum. They’d cover your dress, your chalice – even your coffin. The richer you were, the more extravagant the pieces became. Cuffs and collars of lace could say as much about your wealth as diamond necklaces and gold rings.

Lace collar, Venetian, c 1610. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam

England’s King Charles I, ever the fashionista, demanded 1,600 yards of the stuff for his shirts. Lacework could be used as financial leverage, smuggled across borders, and symbolic of political and marital unions. The lace industry was so hot, that there were actually a government sanctioned lace maker holiday in November, called “Cattern’s day”.

Portrait of Frances Marbury (d. 1634), aged 27, with her daughter, aged 4

First, we have to admit that we didn’t really know exactly how to define lace. Recognise it? Sure. Explain it? Nope. According to the National Museum of American History, it’s an “ornamental openwork fabric created by looping, twisting, braiding or knotting threads either by hand or by machine.” Lace wasn’t so much a fabric, as it was a technique – if it’s a string, you can pretty much make it lace. Its main categories, when we’re talking handmade lace, are “needle lace, bobbin lace and decorated nets.” Each one requires deft hands for such minuscule knotting, twisting, netting and more…

Bobbin lace made on a pillow with bobbins and pins / Wikipedia
Insertion, 17th century. Spanish or Italian / The Metropolitan Museum of Art.
14th century Irish lace. ‘fathomfive / Flickr
Portrait of Thomas Pope, later 3rd Earl of Downe, bust-length, in a white tunic embroidered with gold and a yellow lace collar by William Larkin. (London circa 1580-1619)
Antique Flemish lace work

The base of all lacework was – drumroll – netting! Its origins go back thousands of years, and very word “Lace” comes from the Latin root for ensnare, laceum. It wasn’t until the 16th century, says the the National Museum of American History, that lace artistry blew up in Europe with real extravagance and then spread to America.

18th century Italian lace panel with mythical creatures
A baby Lady Waugh, 1615. Artist unknown.
Borderlate 16th century. Southern German or Italian / The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Portrait of Anna Rosina Marquart, née Tanck, wife of the mayor of Lübeck (1642), by Michael Conrad Hirt (1613–1671) 
Italian lace work. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.

Threads of silk and precious metals were imported from the East, and lace making competitions and guilds were established. It transcended the space of domestic hobby, and became a way to flaunt your status; churches would commission “panel” pieces akin to antique comic books that played out biblical scenes, and it wasn’t uncommon to find lace embellishments on the coffins and chariots – as well as the cuffs – of aristocrats.

Designs from 1906-1915
Details of “Portrait of a Young Woman” by Nicolaes Eliasz Pickenoy, 1632 / G. Paul Getty Museum

Lace, lace, and more lace was the mood for Queen Victoria’s 1840 wedding, from her invitations to the stunning dress itself. Just as Katie Middleton’s royal wedding gown launched a thousand copy-cat homages, Victoria’s frock kick-started another wave of the race for lace…

Queen Victoria’s trendy lace wedding dress
A collar (believed to be Irish) from 1890. / The Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Italian evening shoes with lace accents by Pierre Yantorny, early 20th century
Irish crochet lace from 1850. / The Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Irish lace crochet, c. 1850 detail.

By the mid-19th century, cheaper and quicker means of production were under way. Paper cutouts of traditional lace designs, known as “open-work lace paper” became popular, and cotton thread – instead of gold and silk – was the order of the day.

On the one hand, lace purists may poo-poo the decline of an industry once dedicated to unique, handmade artistry. Totally understandable. On the other hand, not everyone can afford golden thread. The Industrial Revolution helped the romance of lace become a more accessible, and colourful place – consider the influx of 19th century, “paper lace” Valentine’s card cutouts:

A 19th century lace paper valentine’s by Esther Howland / Metropolitan Museum of Art
A lace valentine from 1850-79 / The Metropolitan Museum of Art.
A “lace” valentine 1850–1870 / The Metropolitan Museum of Art.

Men’s lace fashions went out of style by the 1800s and the trade of handcrafted lace took a nose dive from the industrial revolution, Thus, the art of lace making lived on in the domaine of women’s crafts – and as such, became inextricably bound to the way they tell their stories.

Consider the accidental, “autobiographical lace” made by Adelaide Hall. As a patient in a mental asylum in Washington, she used fabric as an expression of her world in the piece below, dated c. 1916. It’s a dazzling work, whose technical skill manages to feel both practiced and spontaneous:

Autobiographical lace made by Adelaide Hall, a patient in a mental asylum in Washington around 1916

The spirit of such craftsmanship lives on in the work of contemporary artists, like Lieve Jerger. Born in Flanders, Belgium – one of the hotspots of lace making in the 17th century – Lieve learned the craft from her grandmother, and since roughly the 1970s has been making allegorical, copper lace pieces on her grandmother’s oak bobbins:

Lieve at work in Belgium, 1977 / Lieve Jerger
Copper lace work by contemporary artist Lieve Jerger

So here’s to a future of art laced with stories, as it were, from across generations. And here’s hoping that the next time we stumble across a bit of lace or a forgotten bobbin, we take a moment to appreciate the breadth of this artistry’s joy. After all, you never know where it will turn up these days…

Photo of “The Urchins” courtesy of Choi+Shine Architects, an exhibit that ran from Sept. 23, 2018 – Jan. 6, 2019

Learn more about Lieve Jergen’s work on her website.