New York’s First Subway was Pure Luxury


15th Jan, 2016


As far back as 1867, the streets of New York were always bustling with crowds of people. An ambitious engineer and businessman by the name of Alfred Ely Beach had a better idea. He wanted to transport the masses by subway. The radical idea was laughed at and initially Beach could only get a permit to build an underground mail tube.


But he took what he could get and simply built the tube large enough to hold his subway cars. And so, New York City’s first subway was born in the form of a pneumatic tube, a giant rotary blower that pushed a single car down the track.


It took only 58 days to complete a single 95 meter tunnel that ran under Broadway from Warren Street to Murray Street, for which Beach put up $350,000 of his own money. During its first two weeks of operation, the Beach Pneumatic Transit sold over 11,000 rides and over 400,000 total rides at 25 cents a fare.


Riders entered the station oddly enough at Devlin’s Clothing Store, a well-known shop at 260 Broadway on the southwest corner of Warren Street. Once inside the station, the Victorian subway riders would find themselves in an ornate “waiting room”, adorned with frescoes, armchairs and statues.

Screen Shot 2016-01-15 at 15.12.06

There was even a gold fish pond and a grand piano playing to entertain nervous commuters awaiting their first ride on a strange new form of transport. The cars, also outfitted with plush seating and Victorian luxuries, could hold 22 people.


This illustration of Alfred Ely Beach’s pneumatic train car, as it originally appeared in an 1870 issue of Scientific American. 

But the whole project was more of a demonstration, running only a single car on its its one-block-long track to a dead-end at its terminus. When the car reached the end, the blower system was then reversed, pulling the car back by suction. Much like a funfair attraction, passengers would simply ride out and back, to see what the proposed subway might be like. It was planned to run about 8km in total, to Central Park, if it was ever completed.


During its first two weeks of operation, the public had showed initial approval, unfortunately, he couldn’t fully convince the people of New York City that his considerably slow and loud subway system was necessary or safe.


Beach was delayed in getting permission to expand it and by the time he finally gained permission in 1873, the stock market had crashed and public and financial support was gone. The subway was shut down within the year. He tried leasing the tunnel out for wine storage and even a shooting gallery but still could not make ends meet. The failed subway was finally boarded up and with Beach’s death a few later, its existence was totally forgotten.


That is until 1912 when the current subway was being built. Surprised workers discovered the old tunnel, where they found the remains of the car, the tunnelling shield and even the piano in the subway’s waiting room.


This group of financiers and city officials get a tour of New York City's first subway in January 1904 while the city's policemen stood by on the platform at City Hall Station. Seated toward the front of the ceremonial flat car are Alexander Orr, August Belmont, John B. McDonald, and Mayor George B. McClellen. (AP Photo/NYC Transit Authority)

They decided to incorporated the discovery into the City Hall station (now itself a disused ghost station), where a simple plaque on the wall commemorates the first American subway.


So, a show of hands for who thinks we should bring back velvet armchairs and goldfish ponds to the modern-day subway!

Photos via NYU Local and the Bob Angle


You might also like


More in Conversation StartersDon't Be A TouristEditor's PicksHow to start a subcultureLife is MessyOff-Beat & Little Known

Hot Off the Press

Editor's Picks


Last Train to Paris

Take the most romantic city in the world and the most romantic way to travel, put the two together and you've got my attention. Paris was the original starting point for the legendary Orient Expres...

Trending 860

Antique Computer Nostalgia

At the rate computer technology is advancing, photographer Mark Richards' collection of computers are indeed historical. These machines are officially antiques. As someone that enjoys pressing but...

Trending 869

Bohemian Grove: The Secret Society Summer Camp

I just spent the morning finding out everything I can on the Bohemian Grove. For two weeks every summer, the 2,700 acre secured private camp in the Ancient Redwood Forest of Northern California, pl...

Trending 2,065

13 Things I Found on the Internet Today (Vol. CXC)

1. The socialite buried wearing a lace nightgown inside her 1964 Ferrari Sandra West was a Beverly Hills socialite and wife of Texas oil tycoon Ike West. When she made her will, she requested th...

Trending 3,483

Inside the Shed of the Antlerman

I'm slightly nervous about posting this article. Not only am I a little freaked out by this place myself, but I have a feeling I might get some flak for it. The problem is, I'm completely in awe ...

Trending 3,453